Keeping and Nurturing
Text
English translation
Original Chinese text
闻在宥天下,不闻治天下也。在之也者,恐天下之淫其性也;宥之也者,恐天下之迁其德也。天下不淫其性,不迁其德,有治天下者哉?
English translation
I have heard of leaving the world to exist of itself and allowing it room, but not of governing the world. It is left to itself out of concern that the people of the world might distort their nature through excess; it is allowed room out of concern that they might alter their De. If the world neither distorts its nature nor alters its De, what need is there for anyone to govern it?
Original Chinese text
昔尧之治天下也,使天下欣欣焉人乐其性,是不恬也;桀之治天下也,使天下瘁瘁焉人苦其性,是不愉也。夫不恬不愉,非德也;非德也而可长久者,天下无之。
English translation
Long ago, when Yao governed all under heaven, he made the world buoyant, and people delighted in their own nature; this was not repose. When Jie governed all under heaven, he left the world haggard, and people suffered in their own nature; this was not joy. Neither unrest nor joylessness is Virtue, and nowhere under heaven can anything endure for long without Virtue.
Original Chinese text
人大喜邪,毗于阳;大怒邪,毗于阴。阴阳并毗,四时不至,寒暑之和不成,其反伤人之形乎!使人喜怒失位,居处无常,思虑不自得,中道不成章。于是乎天下始乔诘卓鸷,而后有盗跖、曾、史之行。
English translation
If people are overcome with joy, they lean toward yang; if overcome with anger, they lean toward yin. When yin and yang are both thrown out of balance in this way, the four seasons fail to arrive in due order and the harmony of cold and heat cannot be formed. Would this not, in turn, injure the human frame? It makes joy and anger lose their proper places, gives life no settled constancy, prevents thought from finding its own ease, and keeps the centered Way from taking coherent form. Then the world first became self-exalting and contentious, conspicuously singular and fierce; after that arose the courses of Robber Zhi, Zeng Shen, and Shi Yu.
Original Chinese text
故举天下以赏其善者不足,举天下以罚其恶者不给。故天下之大不足以赏罚。自三代以下者,匈匈焉终以赏罚为事,彼何暇安其性命之情哉!
English translation
Thus, even if all under heaven were brought into service to reward those within it who do good, it would not be enough; if all under heaven were brought into service to punish those who do evil, it would still fall short. Vast as the world is, it is insufficient for the work of reward and punishment. From the Three Dynasties onward, people have seethed with agitation and made reward and punishment their constant business. What leisure have they had to rest in what is genuine in their nature and life?
Original Chinese text
而且说明邪,是淫于色也;说聪邪,是淫于声也;说仁邪,是乱于德也;说义邪,是悖于理也;说礼邪,是相于技也;说乐邪,是相于淫也;说圣邪,是相于艺也;说知邪,是相于疵也。
English translation
Moreover, to delight in keen sight is to indulge to excess in visible forms; to delight in acute hearing is to indulge to excess in sounds. To delight in humaneness is to disorder virtue; to delight in rightness is to go against underlying pattern. To delight in ritual is to lend support to contrivance; to delight in music is to lend support to excess. To delight in sageliness is to lend support to the arts; to delight in knowing is to abet fault-finding.
Original Chinese text
天下将安其性命之情,之八者,存可也,亡可也。天下将不安其性命之情,之八者,乃始脔卷獊囊而乱天下也。而天下乃始尊之惜之。甚矣,天下之惑也!岂直过也而去之邪!
English translation
If all under heaven is to rest in what is genuine in its nature and life, these eight may be present or may be absent. If all under heaven is not to rest in what is genuine in its nature and life, only then do these eight become cramped and coiled, frantic and bustling, and throw the world into disorder. And only then does the world begin to honor and cherish them. Profound indeed is the world's delusion! Can these really be merely passed over and then left behind?
Original Chinese text
乃齐戒以言之,跪坐以进之,鼓歌以儛之。吾若是何哉!
English translation
Then one fasts and purifies oneself before speaking of it, kneels to present it, and accompanies it with drums, song, and dance. What am I to do with this?
Original Chinese text
故君子不得已而临莅天下,莫若无为。无为也,而后安其性命之情。故贵以身于为天下,则可以托天下;爱以身于为天下,则可以寄天下。
English translation
Therefore, if the noble person has no choice but to preside over all under Heaven, nothing is better than non-action. Only through non-action can the genuine condition of his nature and life be left at peace. Thus, one who values his own person more than governing all under Heaven may be entrusted with all under Heaven; one who cherishes his own person more than governing it may have all under Heaven placed in his care.
Original Chinese text
故君子苟能无解其五藏,无擢其聪明,尸居而龙见,渊默而雷声,神动而天随,从容无为而万物炊累焉。吾又何暇治天下哉!
English translation
Thus, if the noble person does not disturb his inner organs or deliberately draw out the acuity of hearing and sight, he may dwell still as a corpse yet appear like a dragon, remain silent as an abyss yet sound like thunder. His spirit moves and Heaven follows; at ease and without contrivance, he lets the myriad things drift of themselves like dust motes in the wind. What leisure would I then have to govern all under Heaven?
Original Chinese text
崔瞿问于老聃曰:“不治天下,安藏人心?”
English translation
Cui Qu asked Lao Dan, “If all under heaven is left ungoverned, how are people’s hearts to be settled and kept?”
Original Chinese text
老聃曰:“女慎,无撄人心。人心排下而进上,上下囚杀,淖约柔乎刚强,廉刿雕琢,其热焦火,其寒凝冰,其疾俯仰之间而再抚四海之外。其居也,渊而静;其动也,县而天。偾骄而不可系者,其唯人心乎!
English translation
Lao Dan said, “Take care: do not disturb people’s hearts. Pressed down, the human heart sinks; urged onward, it rises. In these downward and upward swings, it is imprisoned and ravaged. In supple grace it can soften the hard and strong; with its keen edges it can cut and carve. Its heat is scorching fire, its cold congealed ice. So swift is it that, in the time between lowering and raising one’s head, it can sweep twice beyond the Four Seas. At rest it is deep and still; in motion it hangs as high as heaven. Rushing and arrogant, impossible to tether—is this not the human heart alone?”
Original Chinese text
昔者黄帝始以仁义撄人之心,尧、舜于是乎股无胈,胫无毛,以养天下之形。愁其五藏以为仁义,矜其血气以规法度。然犹有不胜也。尧于是放讙兜于崇山,投三苗于三峗,流共工于幽都,此不胜天下也。
English translation
Long ago, the Yellow Emperor first disturbed people’s hearts with benevolence and righteousness. Yao and Shun then labored until their thighs had no flesh and their shins no hair, sustaining the bodily forms of all under heaven. They burdened their five viscera for the sake of benevolence and righteousness and strained their blood and vital energy to frame standards and measures. Yet there were still those they could not master. Yao therefore banished Huandou to Mount Chong, sent the Sanmiao to Sanwei, and exiled Gonggong to Youdu. This was his failure to master all under heaven.”
Original Chinese text
夫施及三王而天下大骇矣。下有桀、跖,上有曾、史,而儒墨毕起。于是乎喜怒相疑,愚知相欺,善否相非,诞信相讥,而天下衰矣;大德不同,而性命烂漫矣;天下好知,而百姓求竭矣。
English translation
When such practices were extended through the age of the Three Kings, the world was thrown into great alarm. Below there were Jie and Zhi; above there were Zeng and Shi; and Confucians and Mohists all arose. Then joy and anger became mutually suspicious, the foolish and the knowing deceived one another, the good and the bad denounced each other, and the false and the trustworthy mocked each other. Thus the world declined. Great virtue was no longer of one accord, and innate nature and allotted life fell into disarray. The world delighted in clever knowing, and the common people exhausted themselves in seeking.
Original Chinese text
于是乎釿锯制焉,绳墨杀焉,椎凿决焉。天下脊脊大乱,罪在撄人心。故贤者伏处大山嵁岩之下,而万乘之君忧栗乎庙堂之上。
English translation
Then adzes and saws were brought to bear in cutting, the inked line in marking out and trimming, and mallets and chisels in splitting open. All under heaven seethed in restless disorder; the fault lay in entangling the human heart. Therefore the worthy hid beneath the crags of the great mountains, while the lord of ten thousand chariots trembled with anxiety in the temple-court.
Original Chinese text
今世殊死者相枕也,桁杨者相推也,刑戮者相望也,而儒墨乃始离跂攘臂乎桎梏之间。意,甚矣哉!其无愧而不知耻也甚矣!
English translation
In the present age, those put to death lie one against another; those wearing the hengyang restraints jostle each other; and those subjected to punishment and execution remain constantly in sight. Yet the Confucians and Mohists still rise on tiptoe and fling out their arms amid the shackles and fetters. Alas, how extreme this is! How extreme that they feel no remorse and know no shame!
Original Chinese text
吾未知圣知之不为桁杨接槢也,仁义之不为桎梏凿枘也,焉知曾、史之不为桀、跖嚆矢也!故曰:绝圣弃知,而天下大治。
English translation
I cannot be sure that sageliness and knowledge are not cangues and wooden restraints, or that benevolence and righteousness are not shackles and the binding fit of mortise and tenon. How, then, can I know that Zeng Shen and Shi Yu were not the whistling arrows that heralded Jie and Robber Zhi? Thus it is said: Cut off sageliness, cast away knowledge, and all under heaven will be brought to great order.
Original Chinese text
黄帝立为天子十九年,令行天下,闻广成子在于空同之上,故往见之,曰:“我闻吾子达于至道,敢问至道之精。吾欲取天地之精,以佐五谷,以养民人。吾又欲官阴阳以遂群生,为之奈何?”
English translation
After the Yellow Emperor had occupied the throne for nineteen years and his commands prevailed throughout the world, he heard that Master Guangcheng dwelt atop Mount Kongtong, so he went to see him. He said, “I have heard, sir, that you have penetrated the ultimate Way, and I venture to ask about its subtlest essence. I wish to draw upon the vital essence of heaven and earth to aid the five grains and nourish the people. I also wish to place yin and yang under administration so that the myriad living things may fulfill their growth. How may this be done?”
Original Chinese text
广成子曰:“而所欲问者,物之质也;而所欲官者,物之残也。自而治天下,云气不待族而雨,草木不待黄而落,日月之光益以荒矣,而佞人之心翦翦者,又奚足以语至道!”
English translation
Master Guangcheng said, “What you wish to inquire into is merely the substance of things; what you wish to administer is the ruin of things. Since you have governed all under Heaven, the clouds have rained before they gathered, plants and trees have shed their leaves before turning yellow, and the light of the sun and moon has grown ever dimmer. With the cramped and petty mind of a glib man, how could the ultimate Way be discussed with you?”
Original Chinese text
黄帝退,捐天下,筑特室,席白茅,闲居三月,复往邀之。广成子南首而卧,黄帝顺下风膝行而进,再拜稽首而问曰:“闻吾子达于至道,敢问:治身奈何而可以长久?”
English translation
The Yellow Emperor withdrew, cast aside the realm, built a solitary chamber, and spread white thatch as his mat. After dwelling there in seclusion for three months, he went again to seek an audience with Guangchengzi. Guangchengzi was lying with his head toward the south. Approaching from downwind, the Yellow Emperor advanced on his knees, bowed twice, touched his forehead to the ground, and asked, “I have heard that you, Master, have penetrated the utmost Way. May I venture to ask: how should one govern oneself so as to endure for a long time?”
Original Chinese text
广成子蹶然而起,曰:“善哉问乎!来,吾语女至道:至道之精,窈窈冥冥;至道之极,昏昏默默。无视无听,抱神以静,形将自正。必静必清,无劳女形,无摇女精,乃可以长生。
English translation
Guangchengzi sprang to his feet and said, “An excellent question! Come, and I will tell you of the utmost Way. The subtle essence of the utmost Way is secluded and obscure; its furthest reach is dim and silent. Do not look, do not listen. Embrace the spirit and rest in stillness, and the body will right itself. You must be still; you must be clear. Do not weary your body or disturb your vital essence—only then can you live long.”
Original Chinese text
目无所见,耳无所闻,心无所知,女神将守形,形乃长生。慎女内,闭女外,多知为败。我为女遂于大明之上矣,至彼至阳之原也;为女入于窈冥之门矣,至彼至阴之原也。天地有官,阴阳有藏。慎守女身,物将自壮。
English translation
Let the eyes have nothing to see, the ears nothing to hear, and the mind nothing to know; then your spirit will keep watch over the body, and the body will live long. Carefully guard what is within you and close off what is outside you, for much knowing brings ruin. I will guide you above the Great Brightness to the source of utmost yang, and lead you through the gate of secluded darkness to the source of utmost yin. Heaven and earth have their offices, and yin and yang have their storehouses. Carefully preserve your body, and things will grow strong of themselves.”
Original Chinese text
我守其一以处其和。故我修身千二百岁矣,吾形未常衰。”
English translation
I hold fast to its oneness and dwell within its harmony. Thus I have cultivated myself for twelve hundred years, yet my bodily form has never declined.”
Original Chinese text
黄帝再拜稽首曰:“广成子之谓天矣!”
English translation
The Yellow Emperor bowed twice, touched his forehead to the ground, and said, “Master Guangcheng is indeed what may be called Heaven!”
Original Chinese text
广成子曰:“来!余语女:彼其物无穷,而人皆以为有终;彼其物无测,而人皆以为有极。得吾道者,上为皇而下为王;失吾道者,上见光而下为土。今夫百昌皆生于土而反于土。
English translation
Guangchengzi said, “Come! Let me tell you: that thing is inexhaustible, yet people all suppose it has an end; that thing is immeasurable, yet people all suppose it has a limit. One who attains my Way may be an august sovereign above or a king below; one who loses my Way sees the light above and becomes earth below. Now all the myriad flourishing things are born from the earth and return to the earth.”
Original Chinese text
故余将去女,入无穷之门,以游无极之野。吾与日月参光,吾与天地为常。当我缗乎,远我昏乎!人其尽死,而我独存乎!”
English translation
“Therefore I shall leave you, enter the gate of the inexhaustible, and roam the wilds of the limitless. I shall share in the radiance of the sun and moon and abide in constancy with heaven and earth. What meets me—is it merged into obscurity? What stays far from me—is it lost in dimness? Will all other people die out while I alone remain?”
Original Chinese text
云将东游,过扶摇之枝而适遭鸿蒙。鸿蒙方将拊髀雀跃而游。云将见之,倘然止,贽然立,曰:“叟何人邪?叟何为此?”
English translation
Cloud General was journeying east. As he passed the branches of Fuyao, he happened upon Primal Mist. Primal Mist was slapping his thighs, hopping like a sparrow, and roaming about. At the sight of him, Cloud General abruptly stopped and stood respectfully. He said, “Who are you, old sir? Why are you doing this?”
Original Chinese text
鸿蒙拊髀雀跃不辍,对云将曰:“游!”
English translation
Primal Mist kept slapping his thighs and hopping like a sparrow without pause. He answered Cloud General, “Roam!”
Original Chinese text
云将曰:“朕愿有问也。”
English translation
Yun Jiang said, “I would like to ask a question.”
Original Chinese text
鸿蒙仰而视云将曰:“吁!”
English translation
Hong Meng looked up at Yun Jiang and exclaimed, “Ah!”
Original Chinese text
云将曰:“天气不和,地气郁结,六气不调,四时不节。今我愿合六气之精以育群生,为之奈何?”
English translation
Cloud General said, “Heaven’s vital breath is out of harmony, earth’s vital breath is pent up and congealed, the six breaths are out of balance, and the four seasons keep no proper measure. I now wish to bring together the finest essence of the six breaths so as to nurture all living things. How am I to do this?”
Original Chinese text
鸿蒙拊髀雀跃掉头曰:“吾弗知!吾弗知!”
English translation
Primal Muddle slapped his thighs, hopped about like a sparrow, turned his head, and said, “I don’t know! I don’t know!”
Original Chinese text
云将不得问。又三年,东游,过有宋之野,而适遭鸿蒙。云将大喜,行趋而进曰:“天忘朕邪?天忘朕邪?”
English translation
Yun Jiang could get no further with his questions. Three more years passed, and while journeying east through the countryside of Song, he happened upon Hongmeng. Overjoyed, Yun Jiang hurried forward and said, “Heavenly one, have you forgotten me? Have you forgotten me?”
Original Chinese text
再拜稽首,愿闻于鸿蒙。鸿蒙曰:“浮游不知所求,猖狂不知所往,游者鞅掌,以观无妄。朕又何知!”
English translation
Yun Jiang bowed twice and touched his forehead to the ground, wishing to hear from Hongmeng. Hongmeng said, “I drift, not knowing what I seek; I range wildly, not knowing where I am going. I wander amid the press and bustle, observing what is free of contrivance. What, after all, do I know?”
Original Chinese text
云将曰:“朕也自以为猖狂,而民随予所往;朕也不得已于民,今则民之放也!愿闻一言。”
English translation
Cloud General said, “I had thought myself wild and unrestrained, yet the people follow wherever I go. I cannot get free of the people, and now they take me as their model. I would like to hear a word from you.”
Original Chinese text
鸿蒙曰:“乱天之经,逆物之情,玄天弗成,解兽之群而鸟皆夜鸣,灾及草木,祸及昆虫。意!治人之过也。”
English translation
Primal Mist said, “Disrupting Heaven’s constant order and going against the native dispositions of things keeps dark, unfathomable Heaven from completing its work; it scatters the herds of beasts, and all the birds call in the night. Disaster reaches grasses and trees, and calamity reaches insects. Ah! This is the fault of governing people.”
Original Chinese text
云将曰:“然则吾奈何?”
English translation
Cloud General said, “If that is so, what am I to do?”
Original Chinese text
鸿蒙曰:“意!毒哉!仙仙乎归矣!”
English translation
Vast Obscurity said, “Ah, how grievous the harm! Go back lightly!”
Original Chinese text
云将曰:“吾遇天难,愿闻一言。”
English translation
Cloud General said, “It has been hard for me to encounter Heaven; I beg to hear a single word.”
Original Chinese text
鸿蒙曰:“意!心养!汝徒处无为,而物自化。堕尔形体,吐尔聪明,伦与物忘,大同乎涬溟。解心释神,莫然无魂。万物云云,各复其根,各复其根而不知。浑浑沌沌,终身不离。若彼知之,乃是离之。
English translation
Vast Obscurity said, “Ah! Nourish your mind! Simply abide in nonaction, and things will transform of themselves. Let your bodily form fall away; cast off your clever discernment. Forget the patterns by which things are ordered, and forget things themselves, and become one with the dim, boundless murk. Unbind the mind and release the spirit; be blankly still, as though you had no soul. The ten thousand things are manifold, each returning to its root. Each returns to its root without knowing it. Muddled and undivided, they never depart from it throughout their lives. If they were to know it, that very knowing would separate them from it.”
Original Chinese text
无问其名,无窥其情,物固自生。”
English translation
Do not ask its name, and do not peer into its true condition; things arise of themselves.”
Original Chinese text
云将曰:“天降朕以德,示朕以默。躬身求之,乃今也得。”
English translation
Cloud General said, “Heaven bestowed virtue upon me and revealed it to me through silence. I sought it in my own person, and only now have I attained it.”
Original Chinese text
再拜稽首,起辞而行。
English translation
He bowed twice and touched his head to the ground, then rose, took his leave, and went away.
Original Chinese text
世俗之人,皆喜人之同乎己而恶人之异于己也。同于己而欲之,异于己而不欲者,以出乎众为心也。夫以出乎众为心者,曷常出乎众哉?因众以宁所闻,不如众技众矣。
English translation
Ordinary people all delight in others being like themselves and detest others being different from themselves. They welcome what agrees with them and reject what differs from them because their hearts are set on rising above the crowd. Yet when have those intent on rising above the crowd ever truly risen above it? They merely rely on the crowd to reassure themselves about what they have heard, while their own abilities do not equal the crowd's many abilities.
Original Chinese text
而欲为人之国者,此揽乎三王之利而不见其患者也。此以人之国侥倖也。几何侥幸而不丧人之国乎?其存人之国也,无万分之一;而丧人之国也,一不成而万有余丧矣!悲夫,有土者之不知也!
English translation
Yet those who wish to govern another’s state seize upon the advantages of the Three Kings without seeing the dangers they entail. This is to gamble with another’s state. How often can one trust to luck without bringing that state to ruin? The chance of preserving it is not even one in ten thousand; but let a single undertaking fail, and the losses will exceed ten thousand. How lamentable that those who possess territory do not understand this!
Original Chinese text
夫有土者,有大物也。有大物者,不可以物。物而不物,故能物物。明乎物物者之非物也,岂独治天下百姓而已哉!出入六合,游乎九州,独往独来,是谓独有。独有之人,是之谓至贵。
English translation
One who possesses territory possesses a great thing. Whoever possesses a great thing must not be reduced to a thing. He treats things as things without himself becoming a thing, and therefore can order all things as things. Once he understands that what makes things into things is not itself a thing, could his capacity be limited merely to governing the people under heaven? He passes in and out of the Six Directions, roams through the Nine Provinces, and goes and comes alone. This is called “solitary possession.” A person of solitary possession is said to be supremely noble.
Original Chinese text
大人之教,若形之于影,声之于响,有问而应之,尽其所怀,为天下配。处乎无响。行乎无方。挈汝适复之挠挠,以游无端,出入无旁,与日无始。颂论形躯,合乎大同。大同而无己。无己,恶乎得有有。
English translation
The teaching of the great person is like a form in relation to its shadow, or a sound in relation to its echo: when someone asks, he responds, fully expressing what he holds within and serving as a counterpart to all under heaven. He dwells where there is no echo and moves without a fixed direction. He takes you into the turmoil of going and returning, to roam where there is neither limit nor endpoint; he enters and departs without bounds, and with the sun has no beginning. In praising and discussing embodied form, he accords with the Great Commonality. In the Great Commonality there is no self. With no self, how could there be any possession of being?
Original Chinese text
睹有者,昔之君子;睹无者,天地之友。
English translation
Those who perceive being are the noble persons of old; those who perceive nonbeing are the friends of Heaven and Earth.
Original Chinese text
贱而不可不任者,物也;卑而不可不因者,民也;匿而不可不为者,事也;粗而不可不陈者,法也;远而不可不居者,义也;亲而不可不广者,仁也;节而不可不积者,礼也;中而不可不高者,德也;一而不可不易者,道也;神而不可不为者,天也。
English translation
What is lowly yet cannot be left without employment is the world of things; what is humble yet cannot be left unfollowed is the people; what is hidden yet cannot be left undone is affairs; what is coarse yet cannot be left unstated is law; what is distant yet cannot be left undwelt in is righteousness; what is intimate yet cannot be left unextended is benevolence; what gives measure yet cannot be left unaccumulated is ritual; what holds the center yet cannot be left unexalted is virtue; what is one yet cannot be left unchanged is the Way; what is numinous yet cannot be left inactive is Heaven.
Original Chinese text
故圣人观于天而不助,成于德而不累,出于道而不谋,会于仁而不恃,薄于义而不积,应于礼而不讳,接于事而不辞,齐于法而不乱,恃于民而不轻,因于物而不去。物者莫足为也,而不可不为。
English translation
Thus the sage contemplates Heaven without lending it assistance, finds completion in virtue without becoming burdened, proceeds from the Way without making plans, converges in benevolence without relying on it, treats righteousness lightly without storing it up, responds through ritual without avoidance, meets affairs without declining them, is brought into order by law without confusion, relies on the people without slighting them, and follows things without casting them aside. Of things, none is worth deliberate action, and yet none can simply be left unattended.
Original Chinese text
不明于天者,不纯于德;不通于道者,无自而可;不明于道者,悲夫!何谓道?有天道,有人道。无为而尊者,天道也;有为而累者,人道也。主者,天道也;臣者,人道也。天道之与人道也,相去远矣,不可不察也。
English translation
Those who do not understand Heaven cannot be pure in virtue. Those who do not penetrate the Way have no ground in themselves on which they can stand. How lamentable are those who do not understand the Way! What is meant by the Way? There is the Way of Heaven, and there is the way of human beings. To do nothing and yet be exalted is the Way of Heaven; to act and become encumbered is the way of human beings. The ruler corresponds to the Way of Heaven; the minister corresponds to the way of human beings. The Way of Heaven and the way of human beings lie far apart; this distinction must be carefully discerned.