292. 马嵬坡(郑畋)
正文
现代汉语译文
正文
玄宗回马杨妃死,云雨难忘日月新。
现代汉语译文
玄宗的车驾掉头返回长安时,杨贵妃已经死了;旧日的恩爱纵然难忘,国运却已重新有了起色。
“回马”指两京收复后玄宗由蜀地返回长安,其时安史之乱尚未完全平定。“云雨”出自宋玉《高唐赋》,后世用作男女欢爱的代称,这里指玄宗与杨贵妃的情分;“难忘”写情之深。“日月新”指两京收复、朝廷重光。一句之中,个人之痛与国家之新并置。(“难忘”一作“虽亡”,今从通行本作“难忘”。)
正文
终是圣明天子事,景阳宫井又何人?
现代汉语译文
这终究算是圣明君主的决断;不然的话,景阳宫那口井里躲着的,又会是谁呢?
“圣明天子”表面是称许玄宗识大体、能割舍;“终是”二字却含保留。“景阳宫井”用陈后主的故事:隋兵破城时,陈后主与宠妃张丽华等躲入景阳宫枯井,仍被俘获。诗人以陈后主作反衬:玄宗赐死贵妃,总比亡国被俘强,但“圣明”二字下藏着婉讽。
赏析 · Commentary
咏史里的两难 · An Impossible Choice in History
玄宗一边“回马”收复旧都,一边是“杨妃死”。国家的重振与爱人的死亡被放在同一句里,无法两全。诗人不替玄宗辩解,也不斥他无情,只把这两件事并排摆出,让读者自己去掂量这份“圣明”的代价。
On one side Xuanzong turns his horse back and recovers the old capital; on the other Yang the Consort dies. The state's revival and a beloved's death are placed in one line and cannot both be had. The poet neither defends Xuanzong nor calls him heartless; he sets the two facts side by side and lets the reader weigh the price of that wisdom.
拿陈后主作反衬 · Chen's Last Emperor as Foil
末句把玄宗与陈后主放在一起比:同样是危亡之际、同样有宠妃,陈后主躲进井里做了俘虏,玄宗却下令赐死了杨贵妃。说是“圣明”,其实是说玄宗只比陈后主强一点。讽意藏在“又何人”的问句里,话说得婉转,分量却不轻。
The closing line compares Xuanzong with Chen's last emperor: both at a moment of ruin, both with a favored consort—Chen hid in a well and was taken captive, while Xuanzong gave the order for Yang Guifei's death. To call him wise is really to say he was only a little better than Chen. The irony hides in the question who, then—the words are tactful, but their weight is not light.